Baked To Perfection

91 Main St
Port Washington, NY 11050
No photo available for this business

Business Information


Customer Reviews (13 reviews)

Guest G.

on Judys Book May 10, 2011
This place makes AMAZING cakes that look and taste great - example - I had my daughter's first birthday cake done here. They did an amazing job at a 2-tier cake. Looked like one of those fondont cakes without the... (more)

Guest G.

on Judys Book Oct 27, 2010
Robert designed the absolute most beautiful wedding cake I have ever seen anywhere and I shopped all over for ideas before meeting with him. Not only was it gorgeous but the red velvet wedding cake tasted DIVINE.... (more)

Beth C.

on Judys Book May 07, 2010
hello? Does anyone make Italian bread anymore? A great bakery should have good Italian bread, rolls, pastries- not all cakes! .. I have yet to find a loaf of Italian bread with some taste in this town. Crullers, glazed... (more)

Guest G.

on Judys Book Apr 18, 2010
I've had both experiences at this place, after MANY purchases, special orders, etc. The cakes have always been very delicious, with the caveat that the icing is too thick--yes, it's good quality buttercream, but... (more)

Guest G.

on Judys Book Dec 24, 2009
Management needs a BIG lesson in customer service! I'm appalled with the way I was spoken too....I placed a phone order to find when i got home it was all wrong! The manager/owner was so rude not even offering an apology... (more)

Guest G.

on Judys Book Nov 27, 2009
After they close, they wrap their left over muffins, break fast pastries, pound cakes and re-sell it the nxt day. They keep their cakes in the cake case for days and tell the customers that they were "freshly baked."... (more)

Guest G.

on Judys Book Apr 25, 2009
Baked to Perfection lives up to it's name. The owner works tirelessly to provide the finest and freshest pastries, cakes, cookies and breads. My only choice for a bakery. (more)

Lauren M.

on Judys Book Nov 21, 2008
I ordered custom "store size" black/white cookies (24). This was put on the order. I was charged $3.00/cookie. Paid in full up front (my mistake). Went to get my order today and see they made "small" cookies. (1/2 the... (more)

Guest G.

on Judys Book Oct 02, 2008
I have gotten better desserts from a supermarket. If you are in Port Washington, stick to St. Honore. Baked to Perfection does not even come close. (more)


on Citysearch Jun 19, 2008
I have gotten two birthday cakes (yellow cake with butter cream and raspberry jam) for my friends in the past three months. One is a WHITE BOX W/ PINK RIBBON 8" (for 10 ppl, $25), another one is CHEESE BURGER (for 16 ppl,... (more)
Show more reviews » Read reviews on Citysearch »

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state