Captain Bill's

631-665-6262
122 Ocean Ave
Bay Shore, NY 11706
No photo available for this business

Business Information

Caterers
MasterCard

Customer Reviews (10 reviews)

EastIslipEater

on Citysearch Jul 12, 2009
Sunday Night July 12, 2009 I arrived with a party of 6 to discuss business and enjoy a nice meal. Before I get started please keep in mind that the restaurant was no more than 40 percent customer occupied and not a busy... (more)

denise727

on Citysearch Apr 13, 2009
Best time to go to capt bills is when they first open for lunch! Great service by stehanie and food always good.Prices are double at nite, so try going early and save money!! (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 26, 2008
Captain Bill's was a nice place to eat. The atmosphere was nice and I like the interior decor but the food was just ok. Not a huge selecti... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 25, 2008
I had my christmas party here last year. The food was good and the servers made sure they kept going around not like other places where you... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 23, 2008
Captain Bills is a great place for any kind of party. I have been to weddings, showers, fundraisers and communions here. Every party I atten... (more)

RoryCooper

on Citysearch May 10, 2008
Arrived at 8:15pm Next 15 minutes at the bar - bartender loused up all three drinks. Seated at 8:30pm Waitress did not come to table until 8:50pm Waitress did not come back a 2nd time to take orders until 9:10pm Had... (more)

sammy28

on Citysearch Apr 11, 2008
Average seafood restaurant. A lot of hype that doesn't deliver. Salad came with dinner and had about a pound of dressing dropped in the middle and the ants crawling on the wall kept us good company. Be sure to make a... (more)

classylady1

on Citysearch Feb 23, 2008
Last summer I had a bridal shower for my daughter at Capt. Bill's. I have to say the brunch buffet was absolutely wonderful! Everyone raved about the food. The staff I dealt with prior to and the day of the shower were... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Aug 02, 2005
My husband's family likes to go to Captain Bill's for almost all of their special occasion functions. They have had weddings, christenings,... (more)

CLCARLSON

on Citysearch Sep 10, 2002
Excellent restaurant located on the South Shore of Long Island. The meal and service are fantastic. A terrific dinner menu is complimented by creative and delicious specials prepared each night. There is a great... (more)

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state