Emilio's Restaurant & Pizza

2201 Jericho Tpke
Commack, NY 11725
No photo available for this business

Business Information

Pizza, Restaurants

Customer Reviews (8 reviews)

by joree at Citysearch

on Citysearch Jul 09, 2011
They use peanut oil in their square pizzas and on their focaccia bread! my daughter had a bad allergic reaction to the focaccia bread. there is no signage and nothing written on the menu. if you or your kids have... (more)


on Citysearch Nov 04, 2008
Very dissapointed...they've gone downhill. I have been going to Emilio's for over 20 years and I always tell everyone its my favorite pizza on LI. However, I was living in New England for 3 years and I've come back and... (more)


on Citysearch May 13, 2008
I have been to many pizza places both in NC [where I now live] and on LI [where I grew up]. Emilio's has by far the BEST pizza I have ever had. The sauce is superb and very flavorful and they put on just the right amount of... (more)

Roberta P.

on Judys Book Sep 22, 2006
I grew up in Commack & had gone to Emilio's since it was Carmella's. Those of you in Commack know how long ago that was. I moved to Chicago about 1 1/2 years ago. The people I work with kept telling me that Chicago had the... (more)

Lauren C.

on Judys Book Oct 18, 2005
Always busy and extremely loud. The food is great but a little pricey. Vide variety of food. Everything from pastas to seafood. Fabuouls grandpa and grandma slices. Nice place to have lunch with friends. The parking... (more)

Dominik K.

on Judys Book Aug 17, 2005
Emilio’s is your standard Long Island knock off version of New York city pizza. It’s nothing special and I would even go so far as to call it substandard. Parking there is also a pain in the you know what. All in all, if you... (more)


on Citysearch Mar 19, 2005
Been here twice to eat in (many times for a slice, or take out). The food is of the highest quality and very good all the time. However, the service was terrible. We received both our appetizers and our entrees cool. The... (more)


on Citysearch Dec 21, 2003
The BEST Sicilian we have EVER had!! Sauce is well cooked, perfect crust....... We have moved to VA, but make it a point to visit every time we go to LI!!! Keep makin' the BEST pie!! :)... (more)

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state