Business Information
RestaurantsCheap Eats
performance
| MONDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 10:30PM |
| TUESDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 10:30PM |
| WEDNESDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 10:30PM |
| THURSDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 10:30PM |
| FRIDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 10:30PM |
| SATURDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 10:30PM |
| SUNDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 10:30PM |
Message from the Business
Island Burgers and Shakes serves hamburgers, sandwiches, salads and more. The chicken churasco, a grilled chicken breast sandwich has become a favorite. We make them over 40 different ways using only the freshest chicken breast, produce, homemade sauces, and six different kinds of locally baked breads.
Our hamburgers are worth a try as well. We start with over a half-pound of the freshest, specially-blended prime beef, offer seven kinds of great cheeses, the city's best tomatoes and produce, and six different locally-baked breads. All our fantastic sauces are made here.
provided by
CitySearch
Top Sentiments among Island Burgers & Shakes Reviewers
Good burgers
Great salads
Excellent grilled chicken sandwiches
Great tasting chicken sandwich
Great white milkshake
Tender Chicken Churrascos
Good meat quality
Fresh ingredients
Tasty guacamole sauce
Good fashioned juicy chicken
Customer Reviews (53 reviews)
ARTROB
on Citysearch Jan 01, 2009This place is way overrated! The burgers, dressing and cheese were tasteless! The only thing that had flavor was the bacon and it was overdone. I had my burger on sourdough and the bread fell apart - a horrible option to... (more)
ccc99
on Citysearch May 12, 2008I love love love Island Burger. I order delivery from they practically once a week. I always get the South of the Border burger, but their salads and shakes are amazing also. And I love that I can order online, and the... (more)
foodnyclover
on Citysearch Jun 20, 2007Someone recommended Island Burger to us, as it is hard to find a great hamburger. We tried it and liked it very much. The burgers are charred nicely on the outside and med. rare on inside (that is how I ordered it).... (more)
hrdowning
on Citysearch Dec 25, 2006Quaint Burger joint in a clean neighborhood. A must-do for any burger-lover when in NYC. A great menu with decent prices! Burgers were a bit thick, but still cooked just perfect. I have never seen so many choices for... (more)
aarti15
on Citysearch Jul 16, 2006Island Recipe? The place was cramped, but that was expected from what I read. A good # of combinations on the menu and the milkshake was excellent - definitely shook off the summer heat. As for the burger, it was well... (more)
chrisk11
on Citysearch Apr 25, 2006While the service isn't great the food makes up for it. I always bring friends when they're in town. EVERYONE loves the place. (more)
Susan S.
on Judys Book Mar 10, 2006I know where my bathing suit body went - it was left on Ninth Avenue after one too many black & whites. They are the crowning glory of Island Burger for me. As far as food is concerned, you can order just about anything you... (more)
mrsuperlove
on Citysearch Feb 28, 2006Among the best burgers in the city. Rest of menu is great as well. Salads are huge and delicious. Chicken Churrascos are large and tender. Fast delivery. Highly recommended. Island Burgers and Shake Shack have the... (more)
Jessica M.
on Judys Book Dec 07, 2005I'm determined to get it right here, even if I have to go back 100 times. This is by far the biggest menu I've seen with variations of pretty much the same thing: hamburger and chicken sandwich. You can get them... (more)
celebrityholmes
on Citysearch Oct 29, 2005Island serves a SERIOUSLY GREAT hamburger. I've had take out from there 4 times now since I first stopped by two weeks ago (always the "people's choice" burger) and it's been better than perfect each time. The service... (more)