Milk & Sugar Cafe

49 W Main St
Bay Shore, NY 11706
No photo available for this business

Business Information


Customer Reviews (14 reviews)


on Citysearch Sep 16, 2009
I ordered Lunch to go. The waitress who took my order was delightful giving me her suggestion for a lunch I wouldn't soon forget. The wrap was delicious and came with a fresh salad,plus they had sweet potato fries YUM!... (more)


on Citysearch Dec 29, 2008
We absolutely love Milk & Sugar Cafe. Have been to the cafe on multiple occasions and have ordered the catering for special events. The catering is fabulous, they deliver and setup everything for you. The cafe is also... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Dec 09, 2008
Very fun place for a date, or even to go to with a group. It has a very 'friends' type feel to it with the different couches and chairs for ... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 29, 2008
Good place to relax and eat well Wish it was larger some of the chairs are hard to eat in but a great place to hang out a bit pricey but qua... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 25, 2008
What could be better? The ambiance, the sweets, local folk musicians. I went because my friends were playing there (The Figs) and we enjoye... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 25, 2008
I have dined twice at Milk & Sugar for the Sunday Brunch. Twice I had the same experience. While the staff and ambiance is very nice, I foun... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 24, 2008
Truly spectacular. Portions are huge - I've yet to come home without leftovers. Coffee is excellent. Decor is lovely. A little gem in Bay Sh... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 24, 2008
Love this place, Very cute, good food and a nice place to just meet up with friends for a get together. I would definitely recommend that pe... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Nov 19, 2008
Want to meet at Central Perk like on Friends TV show, this is the place, great ambience! Food is great too! The coffee and desserts are no... (more)


on Citysearch May 06, 2007
The service was terrible. The manager/owner was a piece of work. She was rude and very unprofessional We had no silverware, had to wait five minutes after getting our food to get silverware. My friend ordered a... (more)
Show more reviews » Read reviews on Citysearch »

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state