Pete's Pitaria & Other Food

516-432-1473
4259 Austin Blvd
Island Park, NY 11558
No photo available for this business

Business Information

Restaurants
Restaurants

Customer Reviews (12 reviews)

by Hopelang at Citysearch

on Citysearch Jul 14, 2010
Live in Oceanside and passed the place many times in the fifty years I have lived here. I love gyros and greek salads decided to give it a try. I usually go to taste of greece in Oceanside or Greek town in Rockville centre... (more)

jamesescher

on Citysearch Jul 16, 2009
I've eaten at Pete's for several years and it has become one of my favorite places to grab lunch or dinner. While it will never be confused with a swanky, upscale restaurant it's certainly offers great food in a clean,... (more)

Bergnardo

on Citysearch Dec 04, 2008
My parents are regulars here so I joined them for dinner and my impressions were somewhere in between the two camps below. The layout of the place is a bit cramped but it was nicer than Abe's in Long Beach who offer nearly... (more)

spirof

on Citysearch Nov 26, 2008
I really had a great dinner. The food was very good. The service was perfect. Very casual and comfortable. Can't wait to eat there again. Found myself in the area, just stopped in. I think I made a discovery. Next time I... (more)

kouklamou

on Citysearch Nov 26, 2008
I really like Greek food. This was wonderful !! I visited Pete's Pitaria recently for the first time. I enjoyed dinner very much. Leo took such good care of us. ( we found out he was the owner later). The waitresses were... (more)

zarkedis

on Citysearch Jan 15, 2008
I had to laugh when I read the one comment below that Leo's BBQ Gyro turned him on to "Greek food." Since when does BBQ constitue Greek dining or "fine" Greek food. Decent greek desserts is all I would say. The food is... (more)

mikeysilo

on Citysearch Dec 03, 2007
I agree with the first few reviewers. Seems the last two guys haven't ventured out much. The take out left much to be desired. I got better take-out Greek food in Long Beach & RVC....which doesn't say much. It isn't much... (more)

jpress823

on Citysearch Sep 21, 2007
I have to agree with jbcandoo, the reviews prior are way off base with regards to service. Everyone has there own taste in food, granted, but the service is one of my favorite reasons to go there. Leo is an extremely... (more)

jbcandoo

on Citysearch Sep 21, 2007
I have NO idea what these other reviewers are talking about. The guys who own's the place (Leo) is probably the nicest, coolest restaurant owner I have ever met. Remembers everyones names and orders, always strikes... (more)

kanakaredes

on Citysearch Aug 13, 2007
Ok for "quick served" Greek food...but not the best (I was born and raised in Korinthos). I would consider it a fast food restaurant for Greek dining. Cheap...but I would have paid more to have experienced something... (more)
Show more reviews » Read reviews on Citysearch »

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state