Sarnellis Ristorante

904-269-1331
2023 Park Ave
Orange Park, FL 32073
No photo available for this business

Business Information

Restaurants
Italian
MONDAY:5:00PM-10:00PM
TUESDAY:5:00PM-10:00PM
WEDNESDAY:5:00PM-10:00PM
THURSDAY:5:00PM-10:00PM
FRIDAY:5:00PM-10:00PM
SATURDAY:5:00PM-10:00PM
SUNDAY:5:00PM-10:00PM

Customer Reviews (12 reviews)

Adventurer

on Citysearch Apr 21, 2009
This is as close to an actual Italian restaurant as Ive ever gotten. The care taken in the decor blew me away. I went with a freind and we were not treated "Rudely" (I personally dont like to be patronized, even if i pay... (more)

CETaylor

on Citysearch Mar 01, 2009
Ambiance is like a tired old living room, it smells musty. Extremely rude management. We got the feeling they were very self important and we were in the way. I read another review that chalked this up to European... (more)

leigher

on Citysearch Jan 08, 2009
I have been to Sarnelli's on 10 to 15 occasions. We find that Rosaria Sarnelli, the owner, is the hostess (dare I say it) and is CHOOSY on who she acknowledges and how she treats people (good and bad). On some occasions,... (more)

ghmlaw

on Citysearch Apr 06, 2008
I recently organized a birthday dinner for my wife at Sarnelli's which included sixteen people. We had a delightful dinner and I can say that the service and quality of food were excellent. What's more, the total tab... (more)

blueridgemtns

on Citysearch Mar 08, 2008
Our family tried to eat at Sarnellis based on reccomendations from friends. We were ignored upon arriving for 10 minutes. (There were 5 empty tables plus we had reservations) We had to ask the waiter about the... (more)

jeather

on Citysearch Jul 12, 2007
Best EVER!!! Make a reservation, or you will not get seated and then enjoy. Everything is sooo fresh and tasty. I have to drive an hour but it is worth every min. My in-laws make it there first destination when coming in... (more)

Contributor

on Citysearch Feb 14, 2007
Locals flock to the Italian restaurant for veal, pasta, seafood dishes and cannelloni served at affordable prices. (more)

greggbates

on Citysearch Jun 26, 2006
This place should be in a "BIG" city like Hotlanta, not a little place like Orange Park, but what can you do? Haven't found anyplace in ATL that can touch Sarnelli's, chef Manuel Sanelli is "World Class" He should get on... (more)

ronalddhall

on Citysearch Feb 05, 2006
Three of us travel annually to Jacksonville on business and we always eat at least once at Sarnelli's. In our view, it is the best Italian restaurant in the southern U.S. We actually plan our stay around dining out at... (more)

teosmama

on Citysearch Jan 22, 2006
We tried to dine at Sarnelli's. My husband, son, and I walked in and were glared at by an older female that was seating another couple. We were not welcomed or greeted in any way. A couple minutes later, she came back back... (more)
Show more reviews » Read reviews on Citysearch »

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state