My Tomato Pie Inc

716-838-0969
3085 Sheridan Dr
Amherst, NY 14226
My Tomato Pie Inc - Homestead Business Directory

Business Information

Pizza, Restaurants
Italian
MONDAY:11:00AM-9:30PM
TUESDAY:11:00AM-9:30PM
WEDNESDAY:11:00AM-9:30PM
THURSDAY:11:00AM-9:30PM
FRIDAY:11:00AM-10:30PM
SATURDAY:11:00AM-10:30PM
SUNDAY:11:00AM-9:30PM

Customer Reviews (12 reviews)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Dec 07, 2008
My family and I started going here a couple of years ago. I love the interior of this restaurant it is very quaint, Italian style. The food is very good, it is a little on the expensive side, but they do have pizzas you will... (more)

Marcus681

on Citysearch Jan 16, 2008
Went there once then took a freind there. WOW we had a small pizza, steak and peppers, cheese toppings. We ate it all, the best part was we didnt feel all bloated like you do with any other pizza, this was delicious, lite... (more)

mmltc

on Citysearch Jan 11, 2008
Great Food - especially sandwiches, soups, salads. I highly recommend strawberry goat cheese salad. Pizza is good, it has a homemade taste. Pizza Bread is beyond great- especially when you are dining in and it comes... (more)

anthony2007

on Citysearch Apr 20, 2007
As the owner of My Tomato Pie, I would like to thank all my customers who have supported us over the last nine years. It is you that have made us one of Buffalo?s #1 Independently Owned Restaurants. Without you, our... (more)

need2checkitout

on Citysearch Nov 18, 2006
Very quaint, nice atmosphere and the best garlic bread with spinach and tomatoes I have had in a while! (more)

Contributor

on Citysearch Oct 01, 2006
Gourmet pizza, pasta, focaccia sandwiches, homemade desserts and fried green tomatoes, plus beer and wine. (more)

chilicooch

on Citysearch Jul 03, 2005
Have had some good sandwichs. Services was good and prices were reasonable. (more)

danryan

on Citysearch May 05, 2005
Great family restaurant. The kids will love the macaroni & cheese or the great individual pizzas. The food is great and the services is friendly. And the prices are great! You can actually afford to bring the kids!!... (more)

bizzo

on Citysearch May 05, 2005
Your chicken Foccacia sandwich is the best. My girlfriend also loves your Tomato Basil Soup. (more)

richwhitmore

on Citysearch May 05, 2005
I have dined at My Tomato Pie on several ocations and each time I am overly impressed with my food, service and overall experience. I travel all over the country and wish there was something like this outside of... (more)
Show more reviews » Read reviews on Citysearch »

Recent Comments


My tomato pie is constantly serving up Fresh delicous food. The calazones are mind... (more)
mrstracygerace, May 06, 2011

amazing food. calzones are always a hit. food is always made fresh (more)
mrstracygerace, May 06, 2011

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state